登陆注册
6133700000039

第39章 Cloning: Good Science or Baaa ad Idea(1)

Ⅰ. Reading Str ategy: Dist ingu ishing Fa ct fr om Opinion

Facts and opinions are both used by a writer to support the main idea of a piece ofwriting. In order to attain a higher level of comprehension,you should acquire theability to distinguish facts from opinions in reading. With this ability,you can readcritically,so that you will not accept everything you read as fact.

A fact is a statement that can be proven true through objective evidence such asobservation or experimentation. It is also defined as something that actually exists,orthat everyone agrees is true. But it should be noticed that there are true facts and falsefacts . For example,the statement the sun moved around the ear th is obviously a falsefact as it has long been proven wrong.

An opinion,on the other hand,is a statement that cannot be objectively proventrue or false. It usually refers to one??s personal belief,feeling or judgment aboutsomething. An opinion,therefore,is open to debate even if it is based on fact. Thereare words that can serve as clues to statements of opinion. For example,words like Ibelieve,I think,in my opinion,I feel,and I suggest,show clearly that an opinionwill follow. Words like proba bly,perhaps,usua lly,often,sometimes,and onoccasion,are used to indicate the possibility of other opinions. Besides,opinionstatements usually have“ qualifier words”which represent opinions. Some of suchwords are: best,worst,great,ter rible,and wonder ful. However,looking for cluewords is far from enough for you to keep opinions from facts,as sometimes opinionsmay be masked as facts,which means they can be written so that they appear to befacts. This is especially true when someone is quoted. For example,Paul Freiberger,a technology expert,is quoted in Fuzzy Logic Sma rt Machines as follows: “ It??s atechnology that will change forever the way we deal with machines. ”This is just thespeaker??s opinion,one that would be shared by some people but not likely by all. Aquotation does not necessarily make a statement a fact. If a quotation is a fact,then itscontent must be factual. For example,you are dealing with a fact when Zadeh,acomputer science professor says in the same piece of writing,“ Computers dependupon exact information to do their work. We don??t. ”

Ⅱ. Applying the Read ing Str ategy

In this part,you are required to use the reading strategy you have just learned.

Read the following statements and decide whether they are facts or opinions.

1. The use of the motorcar is becoming more and more widespread in the twentiethcentury.

2. The feeling of independence,and the freedom to go where you please,is perhapsthe greatest advantage of the car .

3. Television is a great time-waster .

4. Television encourages passive enjoyment.

5. According to the August 10th issue of The Youth,out of 30,000 school graduatesin Shanghai who could take the college entrance examination this year ,only 23,000 sat for it.

6. There is not much point in going to college anyway because you can hardly everget an ideal job after you graduate.

7. Statistics show that rapid population growth creates problems for developingcountries.

8. It is only when people??s living standards begin to rise that birth rates begin to fall.

9. The housing reform gives the rich minority rather than the average majority achance to live better.

10. Vacant buildings ought to be turned into apartment buildings for the homeless.

Ⅲ. Reading Task

A. Pr e-r eading act ivity

Since the announcement of the birth of Dolly,the first mammal cloned from anadult cell,the fierce debate revolving around the issue of cloning a human being hasgreatly expanded. After being diagnosed with progressive lung disease,Dolly??s lifewas taken to an end by her creators. Her relatively early death in February 2003 fuelsthe debate. What??s your attitude towards human cloning? Do you think if scientistswill succeed in cloning a human in the near future in spite of people??s objections? Doyou agree or disagree that it??s worth the risk to clone a human being?

B. Reading

Prepare for disaster . That was the level of pessimism when veterinary researchersJonathan Hill and Mark Westhusin got ready to deliver the world??s first cloned bull atTexas A &M University a year and a half ago. And the scientists had good reason tobe pessimistic: several years of animal cloning work had taught them that most clonedanimals never even make it to birth,and the rare ones that do all too frequently haveproblems ranging from physical deformities to life-threatening medical conditions.This cream-colored calf,named Second Chance,was no exception.“ In his firstweek he was near death,” recalls Hill. He had underdeveloped lungs,like apremature baby. He had diabetes,anemia,a skin infection,and so many othercomplications that Hill can??t even recall them all. The calf spent his first few dayshooked up to intensive care machines.

Today,Second Chance grazes serenely in a pasture outside Austin,to allappearances just one more healthy bull in the herd. But if Second Chance??s healthproblems are behind him,many other animal clones have not fared so well. Indeed,the catalog of illnesses in cloned animals includes everything from blood vesselabnormalities and fatty livers to weak immune systems and deformed heads.

Such are the perils of taking cloning out of agricultural research labs and intofertility clinics. What if instead of Second Chance it had been a human baby hookedup to those life support machines? What if the baby had never recovered from thehealth problems,or indeed had died as many cloned animals do? The fierce debateover human cloning shifted from theoretical moral objections to practical safetyconcerns last week as researchers gathered in Italy for the first serious scientificmeeting devoted to human cloning.

Last week??s conference was organized by two experts with experience in cuttingedgereproductive technology; Panos Zavos,who runs a fertility clinic in Lexington,Ky. ,and Italian fertility doctor Severino Antinori. They plan to clone a human withintwo years,and many scientists don??t doubt that they??ll succeed.

同类推荐
  • 用耳朵听最优美的名著

    用耳朵听最优美的名著

    系列图书精选的各类故事、散文、演讲、时文及名著片段,均用词精准简洁,语句流畅优美,将引领你进入趣、情、爱与理的博大世界,使你更加充满信心地去追求梦想。这里有嘻嘻哈哈的幽默故事,有体会幸福与生活的感悟故事,有帮你战胜挫折给你勇气的故事,有闪烁着人性光辉的美德故事,有发人深省的智慧故事,也有在成长路上给你动力的哲理故事。相信本系列图书能为你展现一个美丽新世界并使您的英语学习更上一层楼。
  • 《21世纪大学英语》配套教材.阅读.1

    《21世纪大学英语》配套教材.阅读.1

    本系列教材是普通高等教育国家级重点教材《21世纪大学英语》的配套系列教材,包括《阅读》、《口语》和《词汇》三种,每一种分一、二、三册,供大学非英语专业的基础英语课堂教学和练习使用。《阅读》以提高学生的阅读能力为目的。第一册和第二册每册十单元。每一单元介绍一种阅读技能,并带针对性训练。各单元还配有三篇快速阅读,旨在通过反复训练以帮助学生掌握阅读技能,提高阅读速度。第三册以介绍文学名著为主,通过对各种不同文体和风格的文字进行讲解与分析,以增强学生对文学作品的欣赏能力。
  • 一本书读懂消失的文明:英汉对照

    一本书读懂消失的文明:英汉对照

    《一本书读懂消失的文明(英汉对照)》主要内容包括世界上已经消失的14大古代文明,它们是古希腊文明、古罗马文明、古埃及文明、古巴比伦明、古印度文明、奥尔梅克文明、印加文明、玛雅文明、阿兹特克文明、吴哥文明、波斯波利斯文明、蒲甘文明、楼兰古国文明。曾经的它们抑或奇特璀璨,抑或神奇飘渺,抑或深蕴着乡土文化,抑或笼罩着城市风采,这些早已逝去的文明却留下了醉人的印记,带领着我们走进古老神秘的文明探索之旅。
  • 谜语绕口令英语

    谜语绕口令英语

    谜语和绕口令是英语文学中两种比较独特的语言艺术形式。前者既饶有情趣,又可以启发心智,增进思考和想像能力;后者结构巧妙,诙谐风趣,富有音乐性,最适合口头背诵,深受广大英语读者的喜爱。
  • 课外英语-异域风情录(双语版)

    课外英语-异域风情录(双语版)

    本册书带您了解异国他乡的风俗民情,便于同学们更好的阅读和理解,真正进入文字的内涵当中,准确地和文字进行交流。
热门推荐
  • 重生之惊华天下

    重生之惊华天下

    前一世她在碧玉年华嫁给了北暝寒,从那时起她便注定要守二十三年的空房。一场大火,烧毁了美人院,烧毁了她前一世的梦。再世为人,她决心不在沉沦,定要北暝寒为她腹水东流的爱祭奠。曲江楼上刺杀,偏偏遇到腹黑少主,处处调戏她,步步挖掘她的秘密。她一步步退让,直到抵达南墙,无处可逃,既然不能逃走,便一起沉沦吧!重世魂出,四大家族现,天下将面临一场前所未有的动荡……
  • 风之男孩

    风之男孩

    青梅竹马的司徒静扬(出身武术世家)和程臻致(出身书香门第)高中毕业后,到美丽的杭州西湖畔读大学,接下来的日子,程臻致获得了风之力量,还陆续在杭州遇到了一系列拥有特殊力量的人,而这些人将会给他们俩带来怎么样的际遇呢?
  • 末世无边界

    末世无边界

    末世来临,人人自危,可是!谁说小孩紙就不能称霸末世?!对于一个超级厌世者来说,末世的到来,就是乐园!狂欢吧!女主!女主虽年幼,却早已厌世,好不容易与朋友一起走到最后,却发现,最大的敌人竟然是...此文男主不定,其他重要人物1V1
  • 打不死的高手

    打不死的高手

    当敌人打不死的时候,就是你绝望的梦魇!
  • 帝霸丹尊

    帝霸丹尊

    绝世丹尊,九死重生在一个寒门弟子赵峰身上。自此逆天改命,觉醒帝族血脉,拳打各路天骄,炼丹天赋更是如骄阳般耀眼,脚踩不出世老不死,踏上一条冠绝九天十地的逆天之路!
  • 邪魅复仇殿下的禁忌爱恋

    邪魅复仇殿下的禁忌爱恋

    3个复仇少女和3个帅气王子,本是青梅竹马,却被拆散,但后来她们又回来了,童年夕日的朋友,如今已是仇人````````但她们正准备复仇计划开始时,却被破坏渐渐地~~~~在一次一次的阻碍中孤独樱蒂找到了哥哥。复仇爱恋一一上幕`````````````
  • 相约千年

    相约千年

    是什么样的身份让他觉得“我这条命从来都是不属于自己的,也从来由不得自己。”“死了好啊,不是可以摆脱这仙灵宫弟子的身份和条条约束了吗?其实我蛮期待来世的生活,这样的惩罚真是成全了我”又是什么样的困境让她无惧生死,缘生缘灭,他和她能否兑现千年约定?
  • 花都吸血鬼

    花都吸血鬼

    有时候我们都在隐藏着什么,从睁开眼睛,直视镜子,我们所做的一切都在撒谎,收敛锋芒,整理头发,摘下婚戒,这样又有何不可,又能够遭遇到什么样的惩罚,后果又能怎样?我不过想做回一介凡人,记得上帝曾经说过,一切皆可能被宽恕,但是,倘若扭曲的命运把你变成了别的东西,比如说吸血鬼,这时谁会原谅你呢?
  • 暑夏柒月,晗时见鹿

    暑夏柒月,晗时见鹿

    树深见鹿,天将明;暑夏中旬,柒月见。——久七
  • 异世废材少爷的传奇

    异世废材少爷的传奇

    朱润华在2017年1月1日购买双色球与大乐透,同时获得10倍大奖,本可以悠然自得的过完一生,但坐吃山空不是他的风格,于是就衣锦还乡。。。。。。30岁的朱润华做在飞往泰州的私人飞机里,想起这几年来不可思议的经历,突然,天空电闪雷鸣,空中出现一个金黄色漩涡,飞机被吸入其中。。。穿越了。。。穿越后成为已死的废材少爷,遇上了神秘的老者。为亲情,为红颜,为身边最亲的人,朱润华从废材一步步踏上强者之路。醉卧美人膝,掌控天下权,传言天道巅峰,灵力极致,便能踏碎虚空,穿越宇宙之间。。。