登陆注册
18852700000021

第21章 Tort Law 侵权法(2)

To find a defendant liable for an intentional tort, the plaintiff must prove that the defendant performed the action leading to the damages the plaintiff alleges, and that the defendant acted with purpose, or that he had knowledge with substantial certainty that an act would result in a tortious result. Furthermore, the action must be a recognized“wrongful act”. A famous case in the 1800s involved a hemophiliac child ( Vosburg) who was kicked by another child ( Putney) at school, resulting in severe disability of the leg. Although the kicker could not have reasonably foreseen that the kick would cause severe disability, he certainly could have foreseen that it would cause discomfort, and was found liable.

For example, a plaintiff attempting to prove that a defendant committed the intentional tort of battery must fulfill several factors:

①Intent;②an Act;③Cause; and④Harmful or offensive contact.

Here,“intent”means either purpose or“knowledge with substantial certainty”.“Cause”in an intentional tort need only be“actual cause”; that is, but for the defendant s action the tortious result would not have occurred. The plaintiff need not allege or prove proximate cause, which would indicate that the result of the defendant s actions was reasonably foreseeable.

Common law intentional torts include:

Assault;

Battery;

Conversion;

False imprisonment;

Trespass to land;

Trespass to chattels ( Personal property) ;

Intentional infliction of emotional distress.

Remedies

The main remedy against tortious loss is compensation in“damages”or money. In a limited range of cases, tort law will tolerate self-help, such as reasonable force to expel a trespasser. This is a defence against the tort of battery. Further, in the case of a continuing tort, or even where harm is merely threatened, the courts will sometimes grant an injunction. This means a command, for something other than money by the court, such as restraining the continuance or threat of harm. Usually injunctions will not impose positive obligations on tortfeasors, but some Australian jurisdictions can make an order for specific performance to ensure that the defendant carries out their legal obligations, especially in relation to nuisance matters.

Case analysis

Tort law spans intentional and negligent acts. For instance, Alice throws a ball and accidentally hits Brenda in the eye. Brenda may sue Alice for losses occasioned by the accident ( e.g. costs of medical treatment, lost income during time off work) . Whether or not Brenda wins her suit depends on if she can prove Alice engaged in tortious conduct. Here, Brenda would attempt to prove that Alice had a duty and failed to exercise the standard of care which a reasonable person would render in throwing the ball.

One of the main topics of the substance of tort law is determining the standard of care—a legal phrase that means distinguishing between when conduct is or is not tortious. Put another way, the big issue is whether a person suffers the loss from his own injury, or whether it gets transferred to someone else.

Returning to the example above, if Alice threw the ball at Brenda purposely, Brenda could sue for the intentional tort of battery ( and the action might also, separately, be pursued as a criminal matter) . If it was an accident, Brenda must prove negligence. To do this, Brenda must show that her injury was reasonably foreseeable, that Alice owed Brenda a duty of care not to hither with the ball, and that Alice failed to meet the standard of care required.

In much of the western world, the touchstone of tort liability is negligence. If the injured party cannot prove that the person believed to have caused the injury acted with negligence, at the very least, tort law will not compensate them. Tort law also recognizes intentional torts and strict liability, which apply to defendants who engage in certain actions.

In tort law, injury is defined broadly. Injury does not just mean a physical injury, such as where Brenda was struck by a ball. Injuries in tort law reflect any invasion of any number of individual interests. This includes interests recognized in other areas of law, such as property rights. Actions for nuisance and trespass to land can arise from interfering with rights in real property. Conversion and trespass to chattels can protect interference with movable property. Interests in prospective economic advantages from contracts can also be injured and become the subject of tort actions. A number of situations caused by parties in a contractual relationship may nevertheless be tort rather than contract claims, such as breach of fiduciary duty.

Tort law may also be used to compensate for injuries to a number of other individual interests that are not recognized in property or contract law, and are intangible. This includes an interest in freedom from emotional distress,privacy interests,and reputation. These are protected by a number of torts such as infliction, privacy torts, and defamation. Defamation and privacy torts may, for example, allow a celebrity to sue a newspaper for publishing an untrue and harmful statement about him. Other protected interests include freedom of movement, protected by the intentional tort of false imprisonment.

liable / lai bl/adj. 有责任的,有义务的;应受罚的;

有倾向的;易的

negligence / neglidns/n.疏忽;过失

injunctive /indktiv/adj.命令的;指令的; [律]禁止令

nuisance / nju s ns/n.麻烦事;损害;讨厌的人;讨厌的

东西

trespass / tresp s/n.过失;罪过;非法侵入;擅自进入

incursion /in kn/n.入侵;侵犯

defamation / def mein/n.中伤;诽谤

proximate / pr ksimit/adj.直接的,最近的;近似的

tortfeasor / t t fi z /n.[律]犯侵权行为者

precaution /pri kn/n.防范,预防,警惕;预防措施

detrimental / detri ment l/adj.有害的;不利的

battery / b t ri/n.[法律] (非法)殴打

tortious / ts/adj.侵权行为的,非法行为的

hemophiliac / hi m fili k/n.[医]血友病患者

adj.[医]血友病的

chattel / tt l /n.动产

infliction /in flikn/n.施加;处罚,刑罚

injunction / indkn/n.命令;禁令;劝告

fiduciary /fi djuri /adj.受信托的;基于信用的;信托的n.受托人;被信托者

同类推荐
  • 课外英语-异域风情录(双语版)

    课外英语-异域风情录(双语版)

    本册书带您了解异国他乡的风俗民情,便于同学们更好的阅读和理解,真正进入文字的内涵当中,准确地和文字进行交流。
  • 灵魂也有一席之地

    灵魂也有一席之地

    拥有信心,所有的事情才有可能成功。缺乏信心,即便是最微小的挑战,都会显得无法逾越,难以克服。本书收录的百则经典哲理美文,其内容涉及人生的方方面面,它们有的睿智凝练,让心灵为之震撼;有的灵气十足,宛如一线罅隙中奔涌而出的清泉,悄然渗入心田。
  • 青春阅读-赠言传深情(双语)

    青春阅读-赠言传深情(双语)

    本书主要讲述了双语类的名人名言。本书的名人名言都是赠言传情类。
  • 法律专业英语教程

    法律专业英语教程

    本书将学习英语与了解以美国为代表的英美法律、法律制度,提高实用法律英语操作能力紧密结合,即不仅注重英语能力的培养,也强调涉外法律专业知识的传授和技能的训练。本书除了适合“英语+法律”、“法律+英语”的涉外型、复合型本科生、研究生使用外,也可供法学、外交、国际贸易、国际金融和国际政治等专业的本科生、研究生学习法律和英语之用。此外,对于广大法律英语爱好者及希望了解英美法律和法律制度的专业人士,也是难得的参考书。
  • 一个人也能学好英语

    一个人也能学好英语

    当今社会,英语的实用越来越频繁了。尤其在80,90后表现得尤为突出。实用英语交流几乎成为了一项最基本的技能。就像开车一样,几乎成为了人人必会的项目。看到小伙伴们都能讲一口流利的英语。而自己所学的书面英语,根本不能达到交流的目的。而又碍于情面,逃避交友,社交。建议此种情况,作者根据此类人群的学习和心理特性,特别编写了《一个人也能学好英语》,就是让你一个人悄悄地修炼,等练成出关的时候,一口地道的美语,一定会让你的小伙伴惊讶不已的,羡慕、嫉妒、恨。
热门推荐
  • 大梦三生

    大梦三生

    我叫魅。魑魅魍魉的魅。魑是我的哥哥,魍是我的妹妹,魉是我的弟弟。我们一起住在四鬼洞,在极北苦寒之地。我们不是鬼,不是魂,不是妖,更不是仙。我们不听命于任何人,如果你死了你的魂魄会在被阎王带走时看到我们。我来拿走你的情爱,魑来拿走你的记忆,魍来带走你的怨恨,魉来带走你的遗憾。凡世间流传着这样的传说,如果有人能在极北苦寒之地找到我们,我们就可以和你做一场交易。可以用你的情,记忆,怨或者憾和我们换任何你想要的东西,但作为交换你将再也不会拥有这种情感。可惜过了这么这么多年,只有三个人来过这里。
  • 天才少女恋上校园白马王子

    天才少女恋上校园白马王子

    “这世间已经没有难倒我的东西了,除了他……”这是天才少女,又一次赢得了奥林比克冠军的想法。天才少女过目不忘,长相倾国倾城追求者则可以排到爪哇国去了,可她却偏偏爱上了高冷的校园白马王子。“大小姐,您送的花又被他丢垃圾桶了。”"明天继续送。”"是”直到那一天,"穆小宝你能别再烦我了吗?你真的很烦。”见他用厌恶的表情看着自己,穆小宝眼泪在眼眶里打转。但还是哽咽的说“好。"从此莫小宝再也没有出现在他面前,直到那一天……此故事纯属虚构
  • 柯南之吸血鬼

    柯南之吸血鬼

    他爱好打游戏,偶尔看看球赛打打工。身为终身不眠的吸血鬼,他需要找点乐趣来充实自己的生活。一次机缘巧合,他碰见了遇袭变小的柯南,与组织若有若无的缘分的确让他的生活变得丰富多彩。一次机缘巧合,他碰到了她,一条红线系在了他两的尾指上,切不断。“你知道的,我对我的花儿有责任,她是那么脆弱,那么天真!她只有四根没用的刺来抵抗这个世界。”【注:本书吸血鬼与传统吸血鬼有不同,属作者脑洞原创,欢迎探究。】封面图片来源于P站
  • 末日之粮食战争

    末日之粮食战争

    末日之下什么最珍贵?是夺目耀眼的黄金?是璀璨珍惜的珠宝?还是价值连城的古董?不……这些都不是。那末日之下什么最急需?是智力非凡的天才?是妖娆迷人的美女?还是以一搏百的勇者?不……这些也不是。那末日之下是什么最珍贵?又是什么最急需?我——!……请问,看书之前,您能先看看书名吗?
  • 傲回妖界

    傲回妖界

    妖界我罩了,怎么你不服,不服咱干一架。反正我修为恢复了又不是打不过你。我管你金翅大鹏是不是元凤精血所化,老子我还是混沌神兽的转世呢!我不管你赶紧把妖皇的位子还给我,这妖界本圣罩了。啥子你还是不服?不服,不服有种你也成为混元大罗金仙呀!小毛蛋鸟,老子我就是如此之性你咬我呀
  • 淘金客自传

    淘金客自传

    我是一个常年四处奔波的淘金客,足迹遍布祖国大地,本以为这辈子就这样平平淡淡了,没想到,那年夏天的一次本不该和我有关系的的事情,让我发现了这个惊天阴谋。
  • 邪皇后:强占伪善夫君

    邪皇后:强占伪善夫君

    二小姐唐宁,死里逃生,却蒙上被贼寇玷污清白之名。原本要嫁给惊采绝艳的六皇子她,不知何故竟上错了花轿,嫁了传闻中的药罐子三皇子。残花败柳配药罐子,绝了!世人都说,他们的结合简直是一张茶几,上面摆着一个杯具和一个餐具。可谁又知道?负负得正!当悲剧和惨剧叠加在一起的时候,也会演变成喜剧。
  • 绝色庶女要逆天

    绝色庶女要逆天

    考古系的系花竟在实习中穿越?不可思议的异世之旅即将开始…
  • 虹色魔女

    虹色魔女

    魔女学院里的差生千虹在毕业考试中果、断、留、级!不甘心的千虹主动要求完成补考任务——与一个人类定下契约,让人类以灵魂为代价许下三个愿望。千虹不以为然:“不就是一个灵魂嘛!好办!”可是,她没有看:“注意事项,魔女不得爱上人类,非则灵魂将被困进地狱。”
  • TFBOYS浅爱烊光下的美少年

    TFBOYS浅爱烊光下的美少年

    几乎绝望地看着地板,眼眶明明红的要死,却是一滴眼泪也没有。“浅浅,你不要这样好不好,你哭出来啊!”他心疼的看着她。“我想我们不应该在一起。“她说出这句话用尽了所有的力气,等他走远,整个身子瘫坐在地上。又是一个初夏啊,他们终于在相似的地点遇见。“我终于找到你了。“我还爱你。